Invite a friend!

Gus's New York Pizza

Address
209 Village Avenue Yorktown VA 23693
Phone
(757) 886-5800
Is this your business?
Claim it now!
Something wrong?
Submit a correction
Average Rating
3
Total Reviews
(29)
Leave a review with:
  1. 1 Star
  2. 2 Stars
  3. 3 Stars
  4. 4 Stars
  5. 5 Stars
Is this your business? Claim it now!
Share on
Share

Information about this business (1)

Gus's New York Pizza has three locations. This family owned restaurant offers the best pizza with a wide selection of toppings, delicious oven-baked subs, great sides, and more! The dough is made fresh daily. To assure the delight and continued loyalty of the guest, we are fanatical about each and every detail. We use only quality ingredients. The enthusiastic spirit of our employees, clean...

« Back to business profile

Reviews of this business (29)

Share a review

Overall review sentiment

Score
100%

Top 3 sentiment words

food
Count
1
Score
100%
value
Count
1
Score
100%

Overall review sentiment

Score
100%

Rating distribution

5 stars
4
4 stars
10
3 stars
6
2 stars
5
1 star
4
No rating
0
See more reputation details

Other reviews from the web (29)

Average Rating
80

The waitress was very friendly. The pizza was good. The garlic knots were wonderful. The Greek dressing was amazing.

Average Rating
100

This has been my number 1 pizza spot for awhile now. It's def the best in the area that I've tried! I've had pizza and subs and it's all been great. The staff has always been friendly and they've always got coupons! It's a definite must try!

Average Rating
40

I have to amend my review. Called and ordered a sub and fries to go, the wait was over 20 minutes, even though when I got there, there were few other patrons in the restaurant.The sandwich didn't have fresh ingredients on it...the lettuce was wilted and the tomato looked like an afterthought. It just …

Average Rating
20

Customer service is terrible but the real problem is that I was overcharged for a delivery order and they wouldn't give me the receipt. They aren't very honest, imo.

Average Rating
100

This is the best pizza place around. We eat here all the time. So much that we have met the owner. Great guy! The lady below seems to think that she should receive Queen of England services when...

Good Pizza

Average Rating
80

I've only been to this location twice now. Once eating in and once for takeout. I have been to the Stoney Run location numerous times and just the same as there, the food here is pretty good. I had great service during my visit. It's basically your typical "local pizza joint". I would recommend this location.

good lunch shop

Average Rating
60

Stopped by there today for lunch, We had a group of close to 20. That in mind the food was quick and good. Most everyone had a personal pizza. I had an Italian sub and enjoyed it. The waitress needed help though. The waitress tried to carry too many glasses at once and spilled them on one guest. The management...

Good Food And Fast Service

Average Rating
60

Visited twice with our soccer team, and the service was fast and the food was good. Great place to take the family for a quick Italian/American meal.

Decent

Average Rating
60

The pizza is pretty good, but the crazy bread is anything but... They were quick enough, the supreme pizza was a step up from a chain brands, the sub was completely flattened and had little fillings, the lamb gyro was bigger than the sub, and the fries were soggy. Overall it's decent food for an okay value, but its exactly...

Yum

Average Rating
100

The pizza is enormous and it's certanly New York style! The staff is nice, the atmosphere is quiet and casual. The food is affordable. I always get their jalepino poppers too, delicious.

yuck

Average Rating
40

they have horrible pizza I thought I had seen it all. There pizza is like one of the 1 dollar tombstones you get at the grocery store like cardboard yuck!
the service was ok typical for that sort of place YAWN!

15 min purchase

Average Rating
20

I was on my own this trip and I was recommeded from the front desk to order from them. But I was told that I needed at least a $15 min for delivery. They were a 2 min drive from the hotel!!!! I could have understood $10, but $15 is too much for one person.

Average Rating
40

Stopped by to try one of their lunch specials. Ordered a turkey and cheese sammich. Small sammich on toasted roll. Flavorful turkey and cheese, with mayo,...

Average Rating
80

I live in the area (for the past 2 years now) and Gus' is my favorite pizza in Yorktown. I consistently order takeout from here with my large pizza for...

Ehh

Average Rating
20

Service has somewhat improved from before but still pretty slow waitress' and food takes FOREVER! I got a simple spaghetti pasta dish and it took a good 30 mins. And there was only myself and one other table there at the time. The only thing I have ever had good here are their gyros. Their pizza is nothing like authentic...

pizza is ok

Average Rating
60

We moved here from NYC so we have not found anything to compare. Gus's pizza is just ok the hot subs are not good at all not and are not worth even trying. They do have 9.99 large pizza on monday and tuesdays.

Always a good meal

Average Rating
100

They have excellent subs and pizzas, prices are reasonable...sub specials include great portions of everything for the money!

Very good pizza

Average Rating
80

I don't know whether Gus's stacks up to authentic NY pizza, but I do know that it is very good! There are many great pizza places on the peninsula, so to say that I would go back to this place is saying something!

Never again.

Average Rating
20

Pizza was shoddy, hot wings were undercooked and my sub had brown lettuce on it. All we ask for is a little pride in your food. If you lack that you lack the opportunity to attain a positive review. I will never eat here again and will ensure to inform others of this. It only takes one time. One more thing get rid of the New York, you don't come close.

Average Rating
60

Gus's pizza in Yorktown has good pizza and sandwiches. The "greek" pizza is very good, the sandwiches (during the lunch rush) are quite good for the price. The Newport News location (Jefferson ave) is much nicer and has better service- and the Gyro's are VERY good- but since this review is for the Yorktown location that is not being factored into my rating here. They do have good prices for...

Pretty good

Average Rating
80

We have had take out orders from Gus's in Grafton and Newport News in Stoney Run. The sandwiches are really...

Pretty good

Average Rating
80

We have had take out orders from Gus’s in Grafton and Newport News in Stoney Run. The sandwiches are really tasty with good french fries. We ordered an 8in individual pizza once and the crust tasted and looked like a pre-packaged crust.

Average Rating
80

It's not exactly NY style pizza, but it's one of the better I've found in that area. Large pizzas at reasonable prices as well. Depending on the day & the...

Average Rating
40

With a name like Gus's New York Pizza, I just had to try this place. After all, New York city is the pizza capital of the world, and if your going to put it...

Good food, good value

Average Rating
80

One of the most pleasant places in the local area. The waitresses are always smiling and upbeat. The food is almost always perfect. The only complaints I have are the french fries are sometimes undercooked and they removed Veal from the menu a few years back, made me sad. On the plus side, the owner has a gift for hiring very attractive young women.

Average Rating
40

Their customer service was horrible, and their wings are not BUFFALO, it's BBQ when they claim it's their spicy buffalo wings. Their pizza is suppose to be...

Guss Pizza

Average Rating
80

We go here for lunch and we love it! My son Loves the Pizza and I love the cheese frys! They are freindly and have great food and cheap in prices! AThey also do partys there!read full review »

Average Rating
80

I would definitely reccommend going to Gus's for lunch. Basically all of the meals, from chicken tenders to a personal pizza, to pasta and t...

Average Rating
60

Decent pizza, sandwiches and pasta in a family friendly storefront location. My favorite is the Italian sub. Great service! This is a fun...

« Back to business profile

Business description (5)

Www.Gussnewyorkpizza.Com, Take Out Delivery, Subs, Salads, Pizza, Pastas & Wraps, Over 15 Great Lunch Specials, Burger's

Gus's New York Pizza Inc can be found at Village Ave 209. The following is offered: Carry Out & Take Out. The entry is present with us since Sep 7, 2010 and was last updated on Nov 12, 2013. In Yorktown there are 7 other Carry Out & Take Out. An overview can be found here.

Gus's New York Pizza has three locations. This family owned restaurant offers the best pizza with a wide selection of toppings, delicious oven-baked subs, great sides, and more! The dough is made fresh daily. To assure the delight and continued loyalty of the guest, we are fanatical about each and every detail. We use only quality ingredients. The enthusiastic spirit of our employees, clean...

Gus's New York Pizza is a Pizza, American, and Italian restaurant where most Menuism users came for a meal on the go, paid less than $10, and tipped between 15% to 18%.

Wallet-friendly food can be had in a simple, strip-mall setting. A mainstream menu features such offerings as pizza, subs, burgers, pasta dishes, parmigianas and calzones. Pizza is the main attraction here. Individual pizzas let diners create their own masterpieces without breaking the bank. A variety of salads and childrens selections round out the menu.

« Back to business profile

© 2007-2024 Solfo, Inc. – All rights reserved